Research Note

Psychometric Validation Research Note

Assessment evidence is tied to an intended interpretation, population, and use. Validity is not a general vendor badge.

Aug 4, 20261 min readBy Dalton Anderson
In this article

Psychometric Validation Research Note

Assessment evidence is tied to an intended interpretation, population, and use. Validity is not a general vendor badge.

The EEOC's employment-test guidance says employers remain responsible for selection procedures. The Uniform Guidelines clarification discusses criterion, content, and construct validity.

SIOP's recommendations for AI-based selection assessments emphasize intended interpretation, relevance, reliability, validity, population, and transport to a new setting.

Reliability questions include inter-rater agreement, test-retest behavior, prompt equivalence, scoring repeatability, minimum input, model-version stability, human-review effects, and uncertainty.

Validity questions include construct definition, relationships with adjacent measures, outcome relevance, incremental value over existing evidence, prediction interval, error costs, and the evidence supporting the actual use.

Testimonials, face validity, buyer agreement, correlation with another assessment, or a compelling sample report do not establish selection validity.

Sources

Follow the evidence.

  1. Leadership Quarterly review of constructive-developmental theorydoi.org
  2. situational judgment studydoi.org
  3. multi-study workplace scaledoi.org
  4. Coachability Scale studydoi.org
  5. guidance on employment tests and selection procedureseeoc.gov
  6. Uniform Guidelines clarificationeeoc.gov
  7. media pagefounderready.io
  8. NIST AI Risk Management Frameworknist.gov
  9. Readiness Enginereadinessengine.io
  10. methodology pagereadinessengine.io
  11. privacy policyreadinessengine.io
  12. termsreadinessengine.io
  13. Trust and Ethics pagereadinessengine.io
  14. recommendations for AI-based employee selection assessmentssiop.org

From this episode

Two useful next steps.

Research Note · 1 min

Vertical Development Research Note

Vertical development is an umbrella for theories about changes in how adults make meaning, coordinate perspectives, and handle complexity. Horizontal development usually

Evergreen · 1 min

What Is Vertical Development in Leadership?

Vertical development concerns changes in how adults make meaning and handle complexity. It differs from adding skills, personality, experience, seniority, or intelligence

Return to the episode