Back to the episode map

Research Note

Algorithmic Pricing Terminology Research Note

Which pricing terms describe different mechanisms, and what evidence is required before Venture Step uses each term?

Aug 4, 20262 min readBy Dalton Anderson

Algorithmic Pricing Terminology Research Note

Question

Which pricing terms describe different mechanisms, and what evidence is required before Venture Step uses each term?

Working distinctions

TermWorking definitionRequired evidence
Price testingControlled price or promotion variants used to estimate responseTest design, control, variants, assignment, duration, and outcomes
Dynamic pricingPrice changes with time, supply, demand, inventory, or other market contextTime series, market inputs, decision rule, and price output
Personalized pricingA price or discount differs by individual or segmentUser or segment inputs, comparison group, rule, and resulting offer
Surveillance pricingPersonal data is used to target individualized prices or offersPersonal-data fields, model use, causal link, and individualized output

The categories can overlap. A company could run an A/B test of personalized discounts. A location-based market price can be dynamic without using an identified person's history. Editorial language should name only the mechanism supported by evidence.

FTC usage

The FTC's January 2025 staff study says pricing intermediaries can use precise location, browsing, shopping history, demographics, mouse behavior, and other consumer information to tailor prices and offers.

The study reviewed documents obtained through 6(b) orders from eight intermediaries. It establishes market capability and examples in aggregated form. It does not prove that every retailer or pricing experiment uses every described input.

Legal language

The New York attorney general's January 2026 announcement says the state's disclosure act applies when personal data is used to set individualized prices. The statutory wording and enforcement status need current legal review before publication.

Do not assume that the FTC's policy term and every statute use identical definitions. The public explainer provides conceptual education, not legal advice.

Editorial rule

Observed simultaneous differences establish variation. They do not establish personal-data causation. A company statement that assignment was randomized is relevant counterevidence but not an independent audit.

Prefer a precise factual sentence over a stronger label when the mechanism is uncertain. “Coordinated shoppers saw different prices for the same item” is a supported observation. “The platform used each person's willingness to pay” requires evidence about the inputs and rule.

Sources

Follow the evidence.

  1. ag.ny.gov: attorney general james demands answers instacart about algorithmic pricingag.ny.gov
  2. nist.gov: nist sp 1181 unit pricing guide best practice approach unit pricing 2015 ednist.gov
  3. gs1.org: gtings1.org
  4. search.ftc.gov: instacart pay 60 million consumer refunds settle ftc lawsuit over allegations it engaged deceptivesearch.ftc.gov
  5. stretchgroceries.com: privacystretchgroceries.com
  6. stretchgroceries.comstretchgroceries.com
  7. linkedin.com: andyellwoodlinkedin.com
  8. consumer.ftc.gov: online shoppingconsumer.ftc.gov
  9. steveblank.com: customer development is not a focus groupsteveblank.com
  10. steveblank.com: customer discovery in the time of the covid 19 virussteveblank.com
  11. stretchgroceries.com: termsstretchgroceries.com
  12. andyellwood.comandyellwood.com
  13. consumerreports.org: instacart stops ai pricing experiments a1176475852consumerreports.org
  14. foundersfund.com: choose good questsfoundersfund.com
  15. nist.gov: uniform unit pricing tools consumers fight shrinkflationnist.gov
  16. gs1.org: global data modelgs1.org
  17. gs1.org: current standardgs1.org
  18. ftc.gov: surveillance pricingftc.gov
  19. nber.org: w24489nber.org
  20. nist.gov: best practices uniform unit pricing update nist sp 1181 and nist handbooknist.gov
  21. foodbuyingguide.fns.usda.gov: Aboutfoodbuyingguide.fns.usda.gov
  22. andyellwood.com: founderandyellwood.com
  23. company.instacart.com: the truth about pricing tests on instacartcompany.instacart.com
  24. ftc.gov: ftc surveillance pricing study indicates wide range personal data used set individualized consumerftc.gov
  25. apps.apple.com: id6748532450apps.apple.com
  26. consumerreports.org: instacart ai pricing experiment inflating grocery bills a1142182490consumerreports.org
Venture Step